| |
|
|
| Undergraduate Survey Results and
Lab Manager Comments |
| |
| First of all, I want to extend a
very big "Thank You" to everyone who took the time
to fill out this survey and leave comments. I am very
grateful to you and I want to assure those who responded that I
take your comments very seriously (OK, most of your comments,
obvious ploys to win my favor are ignored). I have, up to
this point, found it difficult to get honest feedback about how
the labs are run and what needs to change. I am also
hoping that your comments will have underscored and echoed some
of my own requests for computing resources. |
| |
| So, below I will list the results of
the Undergraduate Lab Survey and I will include comments
whenever I feel it is warranted. Not all of the questions
on the survey are represented below, for instance, I did not
include the questions about when everyone uses the lab and who
owns what types of PCs/laptops.
If you want to send me some additional comments after reading
this, feel free to email me at
jweltin@bus.wisc.edu.
So, onto the survey. |
| |
|
1.
|
Overall, please rate your
satisfaction with the equipment:
|
|
| |
Very dissatisfied |
Somewhat dissatisfied |
Neutral |
Somewhat satisfied |
Very satisfied |
|
|
Availability of PCs |
8% |
41% |
8% |
36% |
8% |
|
|
Reliability of PCs |
1% |
11% |
10% |
42% |
36% |
|
|
Storage space |
2% |
6% |
9% |
30% |
54% |
|
|
Storage devices |
9% |
14% |
18% |
34% |
25% |
|
|
Loaded applications |
1% |
5% |
13% |
41% |
41% |
|
|
Printer reliability |
2% |
6% |
11% |
36% |
47% |
|
|
Print quality |
1% |
5% |
16% |
35% |
44% |
|
|
Ease of getting print-outs
|
3% |
8% |
18% |
40% |
31% |
|
|
|
2. |
Are your print-jobs
readily available?
|
|
|
|
Response Total
|
Response Percent
|
|
Yes |
|
183 |
93% |
|
No |
|
14 |
7% |
|
|
|
For those who were not satisfied with
the ease of getting print jobs, I want to make a few points:
- I can not control how the
library wants to do their print jobs, all I can do is make
recommendations to them and I will be certain to pass any of
your comments that pertain to the library onto the head
Librarian. Maybe that will make things better.
- Poor service from lab (or
library) employees is never acceptable. I will be
certain to have a word with my staff about being more alert
to the presence of print jobs and the lab users who want
them.
- I, unfortunately, can not grant
undergraduate lab users a print quota at this time.
However, I will mention this to the Undergraduate Office and
see if they would be willing to budget this in for you.
- The other campus computer labs
(College Library, Memorial Library, CAE, etc.) have a
completely different system setup to handle print jobs.
The current VendaCard system was in place before I took over
this position and the cost of switching to a system that
would allow you to print on your own is currently
prohibitive. Personally, I would like to use a system
where your print jobs don't print until you pay for them, as
it would certainly cut down on my paper and toner budget
when it comes to unclaimed jobs. Trust me, I am always
looking for a better way to do print jobs.
- Campus rules dictate that each
building can only have one VendaCard purchasing station (or
something like that). Basically, we are not allowed to
have a machine for you to fill up your VendaCard in the lab.
|
|
4.
|
Overall, please rate your
satisfaction with the computer consultant staff:
|
|
|
|
Very
dissatisfied |
Somewhat
dissatisfied |
Neutral |
Somewhat
satisfied |
Very
satisfied |
|
|
Ability to answer software related
questions |
2% (4) |
8% (16) |
42% (82) |
36% (70) |
13% (25) |
|
|
Willingness to help |
2% (3) |
9% (18) |
29% (58) |
39% (76) |
21% (42) |
|
|
Response time for assistance
|
2% (3) |
6% (11) |
31% (62) |
43% (84) |
19% (37) |
|
|
Friendliness |
3% (6) |
8% (15) |
25% (50) |
37% (73) |
27% (53) |
|
|
|
5.
|
Overall, please rate your
satisfaction with the following items:
|
|
|
|
Very
dissatisfied |
Somewhat
dissatisfied |
Neutral |
Somewhat
satisfied |
Very
satisfied |
|
|
Lab policies and rules |
9% (17) |
29% (57) |
19% (37) |
30% (60) |
13% (26) |
|
|
Cleanliness of labs |
1% (2) |
5% (9) |
15% (29) |
42% (83) |
38% (74) |
|
|
Furniture (chairs and desks)
|
1% (2) |
9% (18) |
16% (31) |
40% (79) |
34% (67) |
|
|
|
6.
|
Is a hole puncher available
when you need it?
|
|
|
|
Response Total
|
Response Percent
|
|
Yes |
|
192 |
97% |
|
No |
|
5 |
3% |
|
|
7.
|
Does the hole puncher work
when you need it?
|
|
|
|
Response Total
|
Response Percent
|
|
Yes |
|
185 |
94% |
|
No |
|
12 |
6% |
|
|
8.
|
Is a stapler available when
you need it?
|
|
|
|
Response Total
|
Response Percent
|
|
Yes |
|
192 |
97% |
|
No |
|
5 |
3% |
|
|
9.
|
Does the stapler work when
you need it?
|
|
|
|
Response Total
|
Response Percent
|
|
Yes |
|
178 |
90% |
|
No |
|
19 |
10% |
|
|
17.
|
Our current opening hours
are Mon – Thurs: 9am-11pm, Fri: 9-5pm, Sat:
9-1pm, Sun: noon-11pm. Do these opening hours
meet your needs?
|
|
|
|
Response Total
|
Response Percent
|
|
Yes |
|
81 |
41% |
|
No |
|
116 |
59% |
|
OK, so it is obvious that I can not
please everyone, so here are some comments about the lab open
hours:
- Grainger Hall is open from 7AM
until 11PM. I can not keep the labs open past 11PM
since the building is technically closed and you are not
supposed to be in it unless you have an after hours pass.
Therefore, I can not keep the lab open until 1AM (or
midnight, or 2AM). This is not something I can change.
- Keeping the lab open costs
money (paying an employee, increased electricity costs since
all the PCs and the printers come out of power save mode,
etc.). If only 5 people are using the lab during a
given time period, it is not very cost effective to staff
the lab and keep it open.
- Current lab hours are the way
the are because no one has ever asked me to change them.
We based the hours on how much use the lab was getting and
cut back on times when it was not being used much.
- I can certainly see about
opening the Undergraduate Lab at 8AM, but if it does not get
much use, I will roll the opening time back to 9AM.
- The strange Saturday hours are
intended to give us a 24 hour window to do repairs and lab
maintenance. I can extend Saturday and Sunday hours,
but it may mean that the lab will have to be closed
unexpectedly in order for us to make repairs or lab
modifications (you users are hard on the PCs).
- Friday hours until 9PM?
We did that once, the lab was empty (everyone was going home
or out for the night). How about 7PM on Fridays?
|
|
Additional Comments: I am going to cover common comments
not covered above, and some unusual ones that I feel should be
addressed anyway. |
|
Floppy Drives:
Sorry, NO. (Although I will try
to get more USB Floppy Drives)
Why you ask? Let me relate an all
too common conversation that I used to have.
Lab Consultant: Shane, I
have a user here who can not read their floppy disk.
Me: What is the error message?
LC: It says something about the
disk not being formatted, but the user swears it worked this
morning when they left home.
Me: Tell them sorry, but
the disk is fried, and the data is most likely not recoverable.
Note: I know a few tricks to
recover lost floppy disk data, but they are rarely very
successful and the recovered data is not always useful.
LC: They say that they really
need the files on the disk, it is their only copy and it is due
today.
Me: Sorry, floppy disks are
notoriously unstable media, especially when shoved into
backpacks or other bags and carried all over campus while
sitting next to small EM emitting devices (calculators,
walkmans, etc.), drink bottles that are sweating, food that is
getting crumbs everywhere, pencil lead dust, and all sorts of
other things that are bad for magnetic media.
So the moral of this story is, that
floppy disks are an untrustworthy way to store your files.
Now, the lab PCs all have CD-RW drives (if they are not working
properly, you need to tell me), plus you can check out Zip750
USB drives (they can read Zip100, 250, and 750, and write to Zip
250 and 750 disks) and USB floppy drives from the lab
consultants. Also, you can use USB Keychain drives (or
thumb drives, sold in sizes ranging from 16 MB to 1 GB of flash
memory, the DOIT Tech Store has 64 MB USB thumb drives for
$30.00). If you have trouble using these, ask the lab
consultants for help. Also, you get 20 MBs of storage on
the server that is backed up almost daily (your desktop and My
Docs folder).
Finally, we hope to soon have the
ability for you to get access to your Grainger files from
anywhere via the web. You will get additional information
on this as soon as it is available. This will mean that
you will not need a floppy disk to move your files around. |
|
Bad Consultant Customer Service/Technical
Ability: Totally
inexcusable. If you feel you are being ignored because a
consultant is surfing the web, playing a game, or doing
homework, you need to let me know.
Also, remember that consultants are
required to enforce lab rules. If they are overly rude
while trying to enforce the rules, let me know, but the fact
that they are asking you to stop doing something is not rudeness
in itself.
As for limited technical ability, we
are working on improving that. |
|
15" Monitors:
Money
is tight people. I'd love to send all those 15" monitors
out the door and at the very least get 15" flat screens in, but
unless I get a rather large budget increase (like $20000 to
$25000 extra), we have to live with 15" monitors for awhile. |
|
Food & Drink:
Ahh, my favorite subject. Let's
start with a little history. When
I took this position, as Lab Manager, the computer labs were
FILTHY! The keyboards and mice were sticky and dirty and
people would write papers thhhhhhhhhat kind a
loooooked like thisssss. The desks all had a rather
unpleasant film on them. It took 5 people 3 days just to
clean up the Undergraduate Lab and we had to replace well over a
dozen keyboards and mice. So, I took a rather draconian
stance on food and drink and I prohibited it completely.
Now, enforcing a no food or drink rule
is a major inconvenience, not only for you, but also for my staff
and myself. However, I need to be able to keep the lab
clean and functioning (no, I don't enforce this rule because I
am a control freak or something). So it basically boils down to this,
you want to drink, I want to let you drink, but I need to keep
the labs clean (I know about the dust, the consultants will try
to keep up with it).
So here is what I will consider.
I will consider allowing closed containers for drinks. I
will also consider permanently revoking the lab privileges of
any person who makes a mess and does not clean it up (I'll
provide cleaning supplies). I'll
formalize a policy detailing the rules, the enforcement, and the
consequences and get it out before Fall semester.
Be responsible about this and I'll
never have to institute and enforce a strict food & drink policy again. That means cleaning up your messes and making
sure your classmates do the same. It also means letting
lab staff know about a mess someone left so we can get it
cleaned up immediately and try to make sure it does not happen
again. |
|
Not Enough PCs:
Another favorite topic of mine.
I agree with you completely on this.
There are 1300 Business Undergrads using room 1295, plus all of
the non-business students taking business courses (no, I can not
deny them access since they may need to be able to use software
not found anywhere else on campus). So we are looking at
22 or more people per PC. That is a tough ratio. If
I ran the world, we'd have 200 (minimum) PCs for Undergrads, but
as I am not yet the Evil Overlord, I can not do this. It
is not my place to try and explain the politics behind why there
are so few PCs for undergrads, but I assure you that I will make
sure the right people see these surveys in an effort to get more
lab space.
On a side note, if you only need to use a
PC for internet access or applications like Word or Excel, I
urge you to try using one of the computer labs in the libraries
around campus. All of these labs should have modern
equipment and should accept USB thumb drives.
For those that think you should have
access to the Graduate Labs, not anytime soon. Sorry,
Graduate students pay a rather hefty tuition differential to go
to school here, and one benefit of that differential is private
lab space and free printing (another reason you can not use the
graduate labs on the second floor, how do I get you to pay for
printing while making sure grad students don't). |
|
Installing your own software:
NO. Why?
Because I would have to completely reload the OS on every PC
every week. Again, I have learned from history. It
used to be that you could load anything onto the lab PCs, and
they were slow, and they rarely worked properly, and sometimes
they were in a different language, and we were constantly
repairing them, etc.
I can not let you just load whatever
software you want. The PCs would be riddled with AdWare,
SpyWare, Shareware/Freeware (which is usually illegal to load in
a lab setting, read the End User License Agreement sometime),
pirated software, hacker tools, everybody's favorite chat
program, email client, media player, etc. All that
software would make the PCs slow and impossible to use, not to
mention many software titles are completely incompatible with
others and could disable the PC, thus requiring me to reload it.
If you want something loaded in the lab
(like a graphics editor such as Paint Shop Pro), you are always
free to ask me (I may already have something loaded that you are
not aware of). However, before I can load anything, I
have to be able to load it on all the PCs in that lab and I have
to be able to do it legally (either by getting money to purchase
enough copies, or by getting permission from the software
publisher to load it in a lab setting). Also, I like to be
able to see a clear benefit to all lab users, not just you,
otherwise you are just wasting my time and valuable computing
resources. |
|
Finally: I
think that covered just about everything. For those of you
that left compliments for the lab staff (or constructive
criticism), I will be certain to pass it on and discuss it with
the lab staff. If you think I missed something important,
drop me a note. Again, I would
like to thank you for taking the time to fill out these surveys. |
|
|
|
|
|